Loading the document
1 free read left. Create a free account for unlimited reading + AI research.
Create free accountArticle
Deconstructor of Fun
Downloads decreased by 46% year-over-year, and revenue saw a 4% decline. The market experienced a period of stagnation.
Mobile card battlers were a quiet, stable segment in 2018, but this analysis argues the calm precedes a major shake-up driven by the expected mobile arrival of Magic: The Gathering Arena. The piece is part of a 2019 predictions series on mid-core games, built on a taxonomy developed with Game Refinery that splits the market into Casual, Mid-Core, Casino and Sports genres. It draws on Sensor Tower data for the top 500 games, excluding China, Japan and Korea, with ad revenue omitted, and the authors caution that figures indicate trends rather than precise values.
The 2018 market held steady on revenue at $303m, down 4% from $317m, while downloads fell 46% to 46m from 86m, largely because Yu-Gi-Oh! had a massive launch in Q1 2017. Hearthstone dominates with a 35% share of downloads and 46% of revenue, followed by Yu-Gi-Oh!. Cygames' Shadowverse takes third place in revenue despite earning over 90% of it in Japan. New entrants such as Marvel Battle Lines drew early downloads on strong IP but faded quickly because of disappointing gameplay and balance, and Plants vs Zombies Heroes likewise failed to dent the leaders' revenue.
The case against Hearthstone's position rests on several indicators. Its average daily Twitch viewership roughly halved from about 50k in Q1 2017 to about 25k, which the authors attribute to infrequent card releases and sparse rebalancing. MTG: Arena saw a clear viewership bump after its late September 2018 open beta, and it has announced a $10m esports prize pool for 2019, about 2.5 times Hearthstone's. Google Trends shows Hearthstone interest declining, whereas MTG's brand dates to 1993. Valve's Artifact, a Dota 2-based card game, lost over 95% of its launch players in late 2018 amid backlash over its $20 price and costly, pay-to-win-leaning card purchases.
Three predictions follow: MTG: Arena's mobile launch will disrupt the market and cut Hearthstone's and Yu-Gi-Oh!'s shares; Arena will surpass Hearthstone in users, viewers and revenue while expanding the category; and Artifact will struggle to gain mobile adoption unless Valve addresses the community criticism.
GoogleCompany · United States · founded 1998 · 2,357 documents
TwitchCompany · 962 documents
ValveCompany · United States · founded 1996 · 719 documents
Dota 2Game · Valve · 2013 · 293 documents
HearthstoneGame · Blizzard Entertainment · 2014 · 120 documents
CygamesCompany · Japan · founded 2011 · 43 documents
Magic: The Gathering ArenaGame · Magic Digital Studio · 2019 · 18 documentsEach row is a game or company this document names, each column a document, oldest first. A mark means that document names it. Select a row to see those documents.
Deconstructor of Fun · 2026