Internal playtesting where team members voluntarily play the game after hours is the most reliable indicator of a project's core engagement.

According to "How Do You Know When Your Game Is Good?": Internal playtesting where team members voluntarily play the game after hours is the most reliable indicator of a project's core engagement.

Developers should prioritize a cohesive creative vision over data-driven compromise, using metrics only to identify friction points rather than to dictate design.

According to "How Do You Know When Your Game Is Good?": Developers should prioritize a cohesive creative vision over data-driven compromise, using metrics only to identify friction points rather than to dictate design.

Success in shooters like Apex Legends is validated through rigorous iteration on 'game feel,' specifically focusing on movement and input responsiveness.

According to "How Do You Know When Your Game Is Good?": Success in shooters like Apex Legends is validated through rigorous iteration on 'game feel,' specifically focusing on movement and input responsiveness.

For narrative and strategy titles like Age of Empires, quality is measured by reaching a state of polish that allows for deep strategic engagement or immersive exploration.

According to "How Do You Know When Your Game Is Good?": For narrative and strategy titles like Age of Empires, quality is measured by reaching a state of polish that allows for deep strategic engagement or immersive exploration.

Teams should rely on personal intuition and a clear design hypothesis to validate their vision rather than using external market research to generate core ideas.

According to "How Do You Know When Your Game Is Good?": Teams should rely on personal intuition and a clear design hypothesis to validate their vision rather than using external market research to generate core ideas.

Identifying 'magic moments' where a project transcends its technical state is a more effective way to gauge potential success than relying on singular, objective metrics.

According to "How Do You Know When Your Game Is Good?": Identifying 'magic moments' where a project transcends its technical state is a more effective way to gauge potential success than relying on singular, objective metrics.

Back to report

Key Insights

How Do You Know When Your Game Is Good?

Push to Talk~15 min full read

01
Internal playtesting where team members voluntarily play the game after hours is the most reliable indicator of a project's core engagement.
02
Developers should prioritize a cohesive creative vision over data-driven compromise, using metrics only to identify friction points rather than to dictate design.
03
Success in shooters like Apex Legends is validated through rigorous iteration on 'game feel,' specifically focusing on movement and input responsiveness.
04
For narrative and strategy titles like Age of Empires, quality is measured by reaching a state of polish that allows for deep strategic engagement or immersive exploration.
05
Teams should rely on personal intuition and a clear design hypothesis to validate their vision rather than using external market research to generate core ideas.
06
Identifying 'magic moments' where a project transcends its technical state is a more effective way to gauge potential success than relying on singular, objective metrics.

That's the gist.

Dive into the full report for the data, charts, and sources behind these takeaways.

Read the full report